逻辑 Critical Reasoning-15668

标记
Metal rings recently excavated from seventh-century settlements in the western part of Mexico were made using the same metallurgical techniques as those used by Ecuadorian artisans before and during that period. These techniques are sufficiently complex to make their independent development in both areas unlikely. Since the people of these two areas were in cultural contact, archaeologists hypothesize that the metallurgical techniques used to make the rings found in Mexico were learned by Mexican artisans from Ecuadorian counterparts.

Which of the following would it be most useful to establish in order to evaluate the archaeologists' hypothesis?

【选项】Whether artisans from western Mexico could have learned complex metallurgical techniques from their Ecuadorian counterparts without actually leaving western Mexico

选项是否正确?

  • 正确
  • 错误

正确的用户笔记

2个赞

helloquin 2014-11-13 12:50:05

没离开M也学到了技术 1. 艺术家不离开西墨西哥就能从厄瓜多尔的副本里学到制作戒指的复杂的冶金技术。 这并不能证实考古学家的推测,因为文中明确提到进行了文化交流,而文化交流必定有人口迁移的行为发生。 2.M是否离开墨西哥与是不是跟E地人学的技术无关,有可能E地人去Mexico教的呢

1个赞

jeffvan 2016-05-16 22:22:44

原文最后一句强调的是M是不是从E的类似的物件学来的技术。该选项的落脚点是M是不是不用离开就可以学到E。 加上该选项的逻辑链是 不离开就可以学到E -> E与M有contact -> 学到这种技术,比起正确选项的E的金属物品有卖到M去 ->学到这种技术,需要多推一步。所以该选项不是最优选项,不选。

0个赞

Cheriez 2015-08-17 02:57:22

Evidence:The people of western part of Mexico and Ecuadorian artisans were in cultural contact. Conclusion:metallurgical techniques used to make the rings found in Mexico were learned by Mexican artisans from Ecuadorian counterparts. (C)The point is learned from whom not where to learn.

0个赞

要拿第一名的神鱼 2017-01-20 20:44:58

第一次练习的时候错选C选项!!因为没有好好分析!后来整理错题的时候秒速排除C项,C项其实早就认定了Mexico have learned this tech from country E (但这恰恰是argument要我们evaluate的地方啊啊啊!)只不过不确定Mexico artists 是不是可以不用离开自己的国家就学到这门技艺!

0个赞

唐豆包 2016-11-06 16:44:41

有可能正确,但我不能理解without那里

0个赞

AngelCHI 2016-10-24 22:15:53

前提:当地人们有联系 结论:技术是M从E学过来的 联系---学技术 联系是否能带来E副本,也就是是否可以带来他们的产品,也就是A C项,学了技术但是没离开M,与联系---学技术无关的,就算他们没离开,他们怎么学到的技术也没解决。所以选A

0个赞

MEDOU 2016-09-20 09:21:23

此选项讨论的目的在于M 的艺术家是否能在不离开M 的前提下从E处学到手艺,无关

0个赞

羊羊羊94 2016-08-05 15:28:40

看错题,其实题目意思是说是否M是从E学来的,错误理解为来自E的M人,应该是come from 才是来自。所以这个选项无关

0个赞

羊羊羊94 2016-08-05 15:24:50

一般如果Yes应该是削弱,然而这个选项里yes就变成了加强。即使是可以不离开学习,也不能证明是否有来自E的M人进行传授。

0个赞

羊羊羊94 2016-08-05 15:24:50

一般如果Yes应该是削弱,然而这个选项里yes就变成了加强。即使是可以不离开学习,也不能证明是否有来自E的M人进行传授。

0个赞

lovehideto 2016-07-07 07:25:34

是否离开墨西哥去学习技术也无关。

0个赞

Scottxing 2016-02-15 22:39:17

艺术家不离开西墨西哥就能从厄瓜多尔的副本里学到制作戒指的复杂的冶金技术。 这并不能证实考古学家的推测,因为文中明确提到进行了文化交流,而文化交流必定有人口迁移的行为发生。

GMAT

考满分GMAT备考平台-公开课天天看,免费提供强大的学习做题
系统,专业优质的在线课程助你迅速提分。

GMAT考满分App

把网站装进口袋
随时随地练习

联系我们